Dear Reader,

I’m writing this from my desk between sessions, thinking about two phrases I hear in my work all the time; and about how only in the unique dynamic of an affair can these two things exist side by side.

From unfaithful spouses who feel stuck, I hear: “My affair partner is my best friend.” And yet, in other parts of my work, I often hear the emotional side dismissed entirely: “It was just emotional.” Both can’t be true.

An emotional bond can’t be the deepest attachment in someone’s life and also nothing worth taking seriously.

Let's unpack that together today: why the emotional side of an affair is the most underestimated, most devastating, and most difficult part to come back from; no matter which side of it you’re on.

Let’s start with what marriage actually is. Marriage today isn’t just a union of physical attraction. It’s built on pillars of connectedness, intimacy, and a shared life; the best-friend bond of supporting each other, listening to each other, being the first phone call and the last voice of the day.

What sets a marriage apart from every other relationship in your life is that specific combination: deep emotional intimacy and physical connection, in one exclusive place. That combination is the cornerstone.

So when the emotional intimacy that was sacred to a marriage gets shared outside of it, the cornerstone isn’t just chipped. It now lives somewhere else.

This is why so many betrayed spouses tell me that discovering the emotional side of the affair devastated them more than discovering the physical side. It surprises people to hear that, but it shouldn’t. Physical transgressions wound. But the shared jokes, the daily check-ins, the “I’ve never told anyone this before” conversations; those were the moments that once belonged exclusively to the marriage.

When they’ve been given to someone else, the betrayed spouse isn’t just hurt. They feel dethroned; sidelined from the position of the chosen one, in the one relationship where being chosen was the entire point.

Here’s the deeper reason why, and it’s something I come back to again and again in my work. As human beings, our emotionality is what distinguishes us. We reflect, we communicate, we bond in ways that reach far beyond survival and instinct. Physical attraction can be impulsive; chemistry can ambush anyone. But emotional connection is different. It comes from the part of our evolved brain that is responsible for conscious choice making. It’s our highest distinguisher as living creatures.

Emotional connection is built through hundreds of choices; to confide, to share, to turn toward one person instead of another. When those choices flow away from a marriage and toward an affair partner, the betrayal isn’t happening at the level of impulse. It’s happening at the level of the evolved, choosing self. That’s what gives emotional betrayal its unique power and its unique pain.

It’s also why “it was just emotional” lands so badly on a betrayed spouse; because the emotional part is the choosing part.

Now I want to speak directly to you if you’re the one in the affair; because you may be reading this with a bit too much recognition for comfort. You’ve said the words, or at least thought them: I love them. They’re my best friend.

That bond is real. And its realness is exactly the critical problem. When someone in an affair tells me they love their affair partner, I know we're not dealing with a fling that will burn itself out. We're dealing with an attachment; formed through the same emotional machinery that built your marriage.

Now, there are two real bonds, made of different fabric, and one decision on the other side of it; a decision only you can make.
​
What nobody talks about is what not-deciding is doing. While an unfaithful spouse stays suspended, the marriage runs on what's left over; and there is very little left over. A bond that deep consumes exactly what a marriage needs to survive: time, attention, presence, and the truth.

I described it recently to a client like this: it's as if your marriage lives in a colander, and everything you put into it is pouring right out the tiny holes at the bottom. That's what it is to live in a marriage that has a hidden affair.

The decision to commit to one bond or the other is the only thing that shifts a person out of spinning in place and allows everyone to begin walking a road forward.

Some people choose their marriage and rebuild something more honest (read: even more intimate) than what they had. Some people leave, but with more integrity and less destruction.

But when emotional resources are flowing elsewhere, it becomes extremely challenging to weigh the decision clearly or fairly. Which is why the emotional part of an affair can become the true kiss of death.

So this week, I'll leave you with the question I ask in my office: where is your emotional intimacy actually going, and when did you (if you ever did) consciously decide to send it there?

Hit reply and tell me what this stirred up for you. Even though I can't respond, I truly value and read every reply, and hearing where you are truly informs this work.

Until next week,

Lauren

P.S. — If you're the one in the middle of this; in love, attached, split between two bonds and unable to choose; The Decision-Making Method is the work I built for exactly where you're stuck. This is that work that shifts people from overwhelm and confusion, to clarity and confidence. Just click right here whenever you're ready. You're not meant to do this alone.

​Unsubscribe | Update your profile | 600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246